Choosing between SBIR and STTR? Run through this first.
Six questions that can save you months of wasted effort.
Before you commit to a mechanism, before you contact a program officer, and before you start building your application, spend ten minutes with these questions. They'll tell you almost everything you need to know.
Where is the science happening? If the research will be performed primarily by your company's team, you're looking at SBIR. If a university or nonprofit research institution is doing a meaningful and essential portion of the work, you're looking at STTR. This single question resolves most cases.
Where did the technology originate? If your technology was developed internally, SBIR is almost always the cleaner path. If it came out of an academic lab and the university holds existing IP, STTR is likely the right fit, and the IP conversation with the tech transfer office needs to start immediately.
Do you have the scientific expertise in-house to execute the proposed work? If yes, SBIR keeps things simpler. If there are genuine gaps that a university partner would fill, STTR gives you a legitimate structure for that collaboration. Just make sure the partnership is real and clearly defined — reviewers can tell when it isn't.
Have you identified a willing university partner? If you're leaning STTR, you need a specific institution and a specific PI before you go much further. A general intention to find a partner later is not a plan. The partnership agreement process is long enough that you need a real collaborator identified before the application is underway.
Have you started the partnership agreement conversation? If you're going STTR and you haven't contacted the university's tech transfer office yet, stop reading this and do that first. Four to eight weeks is the minimum realistic timeline for a partnership agreement. Start the process before it feels urgent.
Have you talked to your program officer? If you've run through all of the above and you're still not sure, this is exactly the kind of question a program officer is there to help with. Mechanism selection is a legitimate pre-submission inquiry. Make the call.
If you can answer all six of these clearly, you're ready to move forward. If any of them surface uncertainty, that uncertainty is worth resolving before you've committed to a deadline.
Comments